On August 20, 1949, the Washington Post put a story on its front page under the headline "Priest Frees Mt. Rainier Boy Reported Held in Devil's Grip." It said a 14-year-old from the Maryland suburbs had been freed of demonic possession after a Jesuit read the rite of exorcism over him 20 to 30 times, and that the boy had screamed, cursed and spoken Latin he had never been taught.

A Georgetown undergraduate named William Peter Blatty read it. In 1971 he published The Exorcist, and in 1973 the film opened on 30 screens and had theaters keeping ambulances on call.

As spooky season gets underway, Disturbing History is running a series on the true history behind some of the most famous and beloved horror movies of all time, and sometimes the true story is more disturbing than anything Hollywood cooked up. The series opens with The Exorcist, and this episode takes Regan MacNeil out of the picture and goes back to the boy. He was 13 years old and lived at 3807 40th Avenue in Cottage City, a mile or so from the town the Post named.

The rite ended on April 18, a month earlier than the paper reported. And the diary kept by Father Raymond Bishop, one of the Jesuits in the room, says he never once answered the priests in Latin. Brian follows the case in the order it happened, beginning with scratching under the floorboards on January 15, 1949, and an exterminator whose chemicals changed nothing. The family had a spiritualist aunt in St. Louis who had shown the boy a Ouija board. Their Lutheran pastor, Luther Miles Schulze, took the boy home for a night, watched a chair tip over, and later told the story to a parapsychology society for laughs.

 A physician found a healthy child and a psychiatrist said he did not believe any of it. Words came up on the boy's skin, and they said Louis and Saturday. A Maryland priest, Father E. Albert Hughes, is supposed to have had his arm slashed during a first exorcism at Georgetown University Hospital, a story that rests on a 1972 newspaper interview and one dinner conversation, while his parishioners remembered him pitching batting practice that same spring.

The center of the episode is the diary itself, night by night, from March 16 to April 18, 1949. Father William Bowdern read the Roman Ritual in a suburban bedroom with the light on while red welts, the word HELL and a devil figure came up on the boy's skin. It took three and four men to hold a 13-year-old to a mattress, and he broke Walter Halloran's nose with his eyes shut. He sang Swanee and The Blue Danube at five in the morning. He was baptized while fighting it, taken by train to Washington and back, and put in a room with a barred window on the fifth floor of the Alexian Brothers Hospital, where on Easter Monday a voice announced itself as Saint Michael.

The second half of the episode is the investigation. In 1960 Bowdern told a young Jesuit scholar, Henry Ansgar Kelly, that there had been no signs of possession at all before the exorcisms began, that the boy knew exactly one word of Latin, and that he had caught his own memory making the story more impressive. Another Jesuit who was present, William Van Roo, told Kelly he saw a sick child. In the late 1990s Mark Opsasnick taped 102 interviews in Cottage City, found the boy's best friend, and asked Halloran the question nobody asked in 1949, which was whether anyone had checked the boy's fingernails. The diary's own entry for April 7 records him writing on his chest with one.

The episode also covers what Blatty changed and what he kept, the letter in which Bowdern told him the case was "the real thing," the production that ran from 85 scheduled days to more than 200, the so-called curse and where it actually came from, and the second layer of folklore the film created, including a vacant lot in Mount Rainier where teenagers gathered for years at the wrong address.The boy grew up, worked about 40 years for NASA, and died in Maryland in 2020.

He never gave an interview. The only account ever attributed to him is six words, reported secondhand after his death.

Disturbing History is a Paranormal World Productions podcast, hosted, researched, written, narrated, and produced by Brian King-Sharp. If this episode was worth your time, rate and review the show and share it with somebody who loves the movie.

If there's a story you think belongs on the show, write to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com.



Email Brian

Get Brian's Books

Leave Us A Voicemail

Visit Our Website

Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation?

Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com.

Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past.

Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets.

Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.